Unqualified Offerings

Looking Sideways at Your World Since October 2001
« « BSG 2.3 Blogging | Main | The Paranoid Creed » »

July 30, 2005

The Second Casualty of War

Has got to be art. Bright Eyes’ “When the President Talks to God” (see the video of the Leno performance) is awful. Apparently some people like the message, but there’s neither craft nor sullen art to it.

(Via Antiwar.com.)

Posted by Jim Henley @ 8:13 am, Filed under: Main

« « BSG 2.3 Blogging | Main | The Paranoid Creed » »

4 Responses to “The Second Casualty of War”

  1. Comment by Ginger Stampley
    July 30, 2005 @ 9:50 am

    It was also available as a free download from iTunes at one point. I’m so glad I didn’t spend $0.99 for that turkey. As it is, it’s unchecked in my iTunes list because I can’t imagine why I’d listen to it and I’m too cheap to throw it out.

  2. Comment by Brian Radzinsky
    July 31, 2005 @ 1:45 am

    Then again, Bright Eyes always struck me as whiny and pretentious. But that’s just me.

  3. Comment by Raf
    July 31, 2005 @ 10:27 am

    Ain’t that the truth. Seems like the kind of song one would write if one were, as the Bard said, telling “an idiot’s tale/Full of sound and fury/Signifying nothing.”

  4. Comment by Badtux
    August 2, 2005 @ 8:27 pm

    I actually like the song (though the performance mentioned sucked). In its “real” version (the one you used to be able to get from iTunes) it’s got flaws, but works quite well. And yes, Bright Eyes is whiney and pretentious — don’t bother buying any of his stuff. This one largely dropped the whine in favor of rage, which made it much more listenable than most of Conor’s stuff.
    It’s harsh to judge a song based upon one live performance by a very nervous kid.
    - Badtux the Musical Penguin