Ike: Soldier and Crusader for Peace
By Mona
*
Apparently, as UO commenter sglover encountered at a deranged person’s site, not only is Jim Webb considered a traitor in certain quarters, but Dwight Eisenhower was also a cut-and-run appeaser. It is absolutely remarkable — appalling and breathtaking, actually — how many presidents or other officeholders who were former military turn out to be virtual hippie peaceniks whom the 101st Keyboarders brand as cowards and like terms. Several days ago I addressed Theodore “Rough Rider” Roosevelt’s wartime insistence that opposition to criticizing the president was unpatriotic and servile (a theme Greenwald excellently expands upon today). Now I take a look at Ike’s views on the same subject (and Ike, as Greenwald notes, “would not exchange salutes while President, because saluting was for those in the military, not civilian Presidents”).
*
The Korean War sent Harry Truman’s approval ratings into the cellar. Ike, a WWII general, ran against Truman on a promise to end the horrific loss of American lives in Korea; during the campaign season, in October of 1952, he delivered his famous I Shall Go to Korea Speech. That oration is only one instance in which Ike unambiguously and emphatically criticized the president “in a time of war.” Indeed, the general insisted that we Americans prove something about ourselves as a nation — demonstrate superiority to totalitarianism — when we go to the polls and pass judgment on the foreign policy errors of a president, including during wartime. Extensive excerpt from that very long speech, emphasis mine:
*
In this anxious autumn for America, one fact looms above all others in our people’s mind. One tragedy challenges all men dedicated to the work of peace. One word shouts denial to those who foolishly pretend that ours is not a nation at war.*This fact, this tragedy, this word is: Korea.*A small country, Korea has been, for more than two years, the battleground for the costliest foreign war our nation has fought, excepting the two world wars. It shall been the burial ground for 20,000 America dead. It has been another historic field of honor for the valor and skill and tenacity of American soldiers.*All these things it has been-and yet one thing more. It has been a symbol-a telling symbol-of the foreign policy of our nation.*It has been a sign-a warning sign-of the way the Administration has conducted our world affairs.*It has been a measure-a damning measure-of the quality of leadership we have been given.*Tonight I am going to talk about our foreign policy and of its supreme symbol-the Korean war….*Now-in this anxious autumn-from these heroic men there comes back an answering appeal. It is no whine, no whimpering plea. It is a question that addresses itself to simple reason. It asks: Where do we go from here? When comes the end? Is there an end?*These questions touch all of us. They demand truthful answers. Neither glib promises nor glib excuses will serve. They would be no better than the glib prophecies that brought us to this pass.*To these questions there are two false answers-both equally false. The first would be any answer that dishonestly pledged an end to war in Korea by any imminent, exact date. Such a pledge would brand its speaker as a deceiver.*The second and equally false answer declares that nothing can be done to speed a secure peace. It dares to tell us that we, the strongest nation in the history of freedom, can only wait-and wait-and wait. Such a statement brands its speaker as a defeatist.*My answer-candid and complete-is this: The first task of a new Administration will be to review and re-examine every course of action open to us with one goal in view: To bring the Korean war to an early and honorable end. This is my pledge to the American people.*For this task a wholly new Administration is necessary. The reason for this is simple. The old Administration cannot be expected to repair what it failed to prevent.*
Where will a new Administration begin?*It will begin with its President taking a simple, firm resolution. The resolution will be: To forego the diversions of politics and to concentrate on the job of ending the Korean war-until that job is honorably done….*A nation’s foreign policy is a much graver matter than rustling papers and bustling conferences. It is much more than diplomatic decisions and trade treaties and military arrangements.*A foreign policy is the face and voice of a whole people. It is all that the world sees and hears and understands about a single nation. It expresses the character and the faith and the will of that nation. In this, a nation is like any individual of our personal acquaintance; the simplest gesture can betray hesitation or weakness, the merest inflection of voice can reveal doubt or fear.*It is in this deep sense that our foreign policy has faltered and failed.*For a democracy, a great election, such as this, signifies a most solemn trial. It is the time when-to the bewilderment of all tyrants-the people sit in judgment upon the leaders. It is the time when these leaders are summoned before the bar of public decision. There they must give evidence both to justify their actions and explain their intentions….*In this trial, my testimony, of a personal kind, is quite simple. A soldier all my life, I have enlisted in the greatest cause of my life-the cause of peace.
I do not believe it a presumption for me to call the effort of all who have enlisted with me-a crusade.*I use that word only to signify two facts. First: We are united and devoted to a just cause of the purest meaning to all humankind. Second: We know that-for all the might of our effort-victory can come only with the gift of God’s help.*In this spirit-humble servants of a proud ideal-we do soberly say: This is a crusade.

Trackback by Unpartisan.com Political News and Blog Aggregator —
January 27, 2007 @ 12:33 pm
Warner Backs Resolution Opposing Troop Increase…
Sen. John W. Warner (R-Va.), the former chairman of the Senate Armed Services Committee, yesterday …
Comment by sglover —
January 27, 2007 @ 7:01 pm
Unfortunately, your link reveals my embarrassing mixed metaphor, “It’s time to swab the decks of this fever swamp with rabies vaccine.” I should’ve said, fever SHIP. Someday I’ll learn to proofread.
Comment by Pug —
January 27, 2007 @ 9:44 pm
The traitors are coming out of the woodwork. I guess they used to be closet traitors. You know, Webb, Hagel, Brownback, Warner, Collins, Colin Powell, Scowcroft, James Baker and on and on. All Democrats have always been traitors. In fact, it seems the American people are now traitors.
Trackback by Seroquel xr. —
July 20, 2008 @ 6:13 pm
Seroquel xr….
Seroquel xr….